India was one of the 35 countries which abstained in the UN resolution condemning the Russian invasion of Ukraine, joining the company of an unlikely bunch like China and Pakistan. It is rare to see India, China and Pakistan on the same side of the fence. While this was derided in the West, I can see hot debates in the Indian media, giving justifications of how Soviet Union came to India's help during the 1971 war against Pakistan when it was threatened by both the US and UK. There is also a ground reality that India depends greatly on Russian military hardware for its own defense and is loathe to aggravate an ally.
Looking at the rear view mirror for such justifications may be purely meant for getting eyeballs by overeager TV anchors of reality news shows. One could easily rebut that argument by asking where Russia was when India was attacked by China as recent as last year. A more clear-eyed view suggests that the real reason for Soviet Union to side with India was the fact that India was an ally in the Cold War against the West and a big customer for Soviet arms. Soviet Union was acting in self interest and no special love for India then just as India is doing now by choosing to stay neutral.
However the position that India is taking may actually help it in the long run establish global leadership in what is becoming a multi-polar world. India's dream of being non-aligned, in the 2oth century, was a bit ahead of time when the world was carved out between the two superpowers - USA and Soviet Union - leaving no space for another power center.
In the 21st century we are seeing in real time the decline of superpowers. The US surrendered that title with its ignominious exit from Afghanistan. Its inability to prevent Russia from invading Ukraine, in spite of several efforts both diplomatic and otherwise, cements that fact and points to the new reality. Russia, for all its perceived might, has also shown that it is by no means a super power. Within a week of its unjustifiable invasion of Ukraine, it has demonstrated a shambolic military strategy, its inability to counter the global rage and repulsion and has reduced itself to a pariah at the level of North Korea. China may want to flex its muscles as a wannabe superpower but lacks the global alliances to attack others at will. With Germany shaking off its post-WWII self-imposed pledge to significantly arm itself, we will see it emerge as a major military power within the next few years.
In a potential future global conflict , it is increasingly clear that both Russia and China will align against the West and move in lock step. China needs oil and commodities and Russia needs economic support. As Germany becomes stronger and provides more leadership in the Europe, US influence will decline. This will result in multiple large power centers - USA, European Union, Russia and its vassal states, China and India. Countries like Japan, Korea and Australia will continue to be wedded to the US and provide a limited presence in the Asia Pacific region to counterbalance China. African and South American countries will possibly choose one or the other alliance.
India's biggest threat comes from the potential of a major conflict with China in the future. Russia is unlikely to support India and despite the Quad, the Western allies may provide moral and logistical support but will not get directly involved. If there is a World War on the scale of the last two wars in the previous century, and we truly hope and pray that does not happen, then India will be forced to abandon its neutrality and pick a side - most with the West.
However for now India can demonstrate global leadership by focusing on how to bring about peace. This war will weaken Russia considerably and drive it closer to China which is not in India's interest. Indians feel that this war is a problem of the West with Russia and nothing to do with them - unfortunately it is hard to compartmentalize such conflicts and assume that they will not show up at our own doorstep sooner or later.
India is the only major country which has the trust of both the Russian bloc and the West. China has lost some of its sheen with the West especially after the COVID crisis but still has significant influence on Russia. Both countries have large populations that need the West for their products and services and hence have enormous stakes in maintaining status quo. They both need Russia albeit for different reasons. If this war spins out of control, the West has the resources to weather the storm but emerging countries will be devastated and lose many years of growth.
It is time for India to forge a partnership with China, however opportunistic and temporary it may be, to lean on Russia to stop the war and bring it to the negotiating table. India will demonstrate true leadership at a time of global crisis and will emerge on the global stage with a position it has aspired for long - a truly non-aligned global power.
Comments