Skip to main content

The choice between non-violence and non-existence still remains fuzzy

On April 3rd, 1968, Dr. Martin Luther King gave his last speech at the Mason Temple in Memphis. He quoted Mahatma Gandhi when he said - ' The choice before us is no longer violence or non-violence. It's non-violence or non-existence'.

More than half a century later, we stand on the world stage as we watch the complete devastation left behind by a barbaric Russian Ukraine war with its most recent example in the town of Bucha and wonder whether we face the same Hobson's choice. 

'The danger with hatred is, once you start in on it, you get a hundred times more than you bargained for. Once you start, you can't stop' Philip Roth in the "The Human Stain" The seeds of hatred have already been firmly planted in the fields of Ukraine. And, as per recent opinion polls, even in the minds of many Russians who have started backing their ruler in this unjustifiable war.

As the Ukrainians fight valiantly for their homeland and even start winning back territory, there is hope against hope that the war will end somehow. An uneasy truce, if it happens, is unlikely to heal the grevious wounds. Most of such extreme wars don't end until a cataclysmic event finally takes all the venom out of the system. World War 1 never ended till the end of World War 2's apocalyptical end with the dropping of nuclear bombs on Japan and the utter devastation of Germany and many parts of Europe. We sincerely hope and pray that no such event happens in this war but we also know from history that wars do not end well and often set the stage for even bigger conflicts.

Never before has the term 'non-existence' been more exigent as today.  Even though most of world has got inured by the continuous coverage of this devastating war, one cannot imagine how much more worse it could become if there is a miscalculation.

The threat of 'non-existence' also came from another part of the world, last week. We saw the breakage of largest ice shelf in Antarctica , the size of the New York city, as a result of extreme temperatures to the extent of 70 degrees F above normal. Sea levels can rise by 180 feet within the next decades submerging every coastal city in the world.

We have simultaneously two wars to be concerned about - the more immediate war in Europe which could easily spin out of control and the  continuing war against climate change. It may sound dire but also trite...have we not heard all this before. Should we just yawn and get on with our lives saying all this hardly matters to us as it is too far away or there is nothing much that we can do about either. Well if so, speak to the Ukrainians who probably were sipping coffee in Kyiv on the morning of February 23rd 2022, pooh pooing all the warnings that were being given to them about Russian intentions. In just a blink of an eye, 44 Million people were turned from leading normal lives that we all identify with to scrambling for their lives. Bustling cities and towns are now utter wasteland. It has happened right before our eyes in a matter of days and weeks. If it can happen in Ukraine, it can happen elsewhere and history has shown that the snowball effect can deliver unintended consequences.

The message from Gandhi and MLK has more urgency today than it had in 1949 or 1968. At neither time, the world stood at the precipice of an existential crisis. The solution they offered remains equally relevant - respond to violence with non-violence and to hatred with love.

If we want to look for one such example, look no further than the Oscar night last weekend, and take inspiration from Chris Rock who bore violence and humiliation both physical and verbal on a global stage with a dignity and poise that will remembered for long. Or at the Ukrainians who overcame their initial reluctance to be baited into war and are showing the world the true definition of valor and are fighting hard to defend their land but also leaving the door open for peace.

Tomorrow - April 4th -is a solemn day and as we remember Dr. Martin Luther King it may be worthwhile reflecting on what we can do in our individual lives to propagate non-violence and love in thought, word and deed. Every little bit will help.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Resolving the Russia-Ukraine crisis- an opportunity for India to demonstrate global leadership

India was one of the 35 countries which abstained in the UN resolution condemning the Russian invasion of Ukraine, joining the company of an unlikely bunch like China and Pakistan. It is rare to see India, China and Pakistan on the same side of the fence. While this was derided in the West, I can see hot debates in the Indian media, giving justifications of how Soviet Union came to India's help during the 1971 war against Pakistan when it was threatened by both the US and UK.  There is also a ground reality that India depends greatly on Russian military hardware for its own defense and is loathe to aggravate an ally. Looking at the rear view mirror for such justifications may be purely meant for getting eyeballs by overeager TV anchors of reality news shows. One could easily rebut that argument by asking where Russia was when India was attacked by China as recent as last year.  A more clear-eyed view suggests that the real reason for Soviet Union to side with India was the fac...

#Unbroken India : From Artificial Intelligence to Tribal Wisdom

Today, India is celebrating its 74th Republic Day - a day filled with great pride and joy. The grand Republic Day parade is considered as one of the most spectacular events in the world, showcasing the country's strength and diversity . However, this day comes close on the heels of a series of other interesting headlines, just to name a few - Ashoka Mody, former IMF economist previewing his book - India is Broken, A People Betrayed Independence to Today; India becoming the cynosure of attention at the recently concluded WEF Davos Summit and India taking the pole position in population after China   posted its first decline in population. I embarked on my own journey across India visiting 4 of the largest metros – Delhi NCR, Mumbai, Bangalore and Pune, 2 upcoming metros – Nagpur and Mangalore and a couple of villages including a tribal village in Karnataka. I met corporate chieftains, spiritual leaders, entertainers, venture capitalists and at least three billionaires, while als...

Is it a great time to be American

'The country is extremely divided'; 'The Disunited States of America'; 'The Divided States of America' "Public Trust in Government at an all time low" There is no shortage of gloom and doom this July 4th as we face rampaging inflation, a slowing economy, shrinking confidence in our democratic institutions, climate crisis, widening income inequality.  Regardless of whether one is on the right, left or center of the political spectrum, Americans don't find themselves in a particularly hopeful or cheerful state, as evidenced by many surveys in the last few months.( US poll on mood of the people ) The question of the day - 'is there still hope' or are we just careening down a disastrous path with no end in sight. America has always been a country of sharply divided views - an inherent feature of a two party system - but in recent years this gap is making people feel that the two parties live in different countries. On the ground however the sit...